22 Mar Art and Accountability: Exploring the Impact of AML Regulations on the UK Art Scene
The UK art market is undergoing a transformation due to the tightening of Anti-Money Laundering (AML) regulations. The implementation of the EU’s 5th AML Directive has increased the focus on transparency and due diligence in art transactions. Art Market Participants (AMPs), including art dealers, galleries, and auction houses, must now adhere to strict AML policies.
Recent updates have brought some clarity, particularly for smaller entities. Artists selling their own work and their estates are now exempt from the Money Laundering Regulations (MLRs), easing the regulatory burden on individual creators. Adjustments to the guidance on ‘business relationships’ and Customer Due Diligence (CDD) measures aim to make compliance more manageable for art market entities.
These changes highlight the UK’s commitment to combating money laundering in the art sector while balancing the need for regulation with the operational realities of the market.
Understanding the AML Legislation
The Money Laundering Regulations 2017 (MLRs) in the UK have been updated to include Art Market Participants (AMPs) as regulated entities. AMPs are defined as individuals or companies involved in trading or acting as intermediaries in the buying or selling of works of art where the transaction value, or a series of linked transactions, amounts to €10,000 or more. The regulations also apply to operators of freeports storing works of art valued at or above this threshold. Intermediaries in the art market can include art dealers, agents, auction houses, and online sales platforms that sell to UK customers.
Compliance Requirements for AMPs
AMPs must comply with several key requirements under the MLRs:
- Registration with HMRC: AMPs must register with HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) if they meet the criteria outlined in the regulations.
- AML Policy: AMPs are required to maintain a written anti-money laundering policy that addresses the specific risks associated with their business.
- Customer Due Diligence (CDD): Before concluding any transaction, AMPs must carry out CDD measures to verify the identity of their customers and understand the nature of their business relationship.
- Record Keeping: AMPs must keep records of CDD and transactions for at least five years and make them available to HMRC upon request.
Non-compliance with these requirements can lead to fines, criminal prosecution, and reputational damage. AMPs may also be removed from the anti-money laundering register if they fail to pay the correct fees for annual supervision.
Challenges and Criticisms
Small galleries and art market participants face several challenges in complying with AML regulations. The complexity and cost of implementing effective AML measures can be burdensome, particularly for smaller entities with limited resources. These challenges include the need for specialised knowledge to conduct risk assessments and due diligence, as well as the investment in systems and training to ensure compliance. The art market’s history of privacy and discretion, combined with the use of intermediaries and legal persons, can hide the ultimate seller or purchaser, increasing the risk of money laundering. Additionally, the art market’s diverse nature, including dealers, auction houses, storage facilities, and art advisors, adds to the complexity of compliance.
Critics argue that the AML requirements for art market participants are onerous and may disproportionately affect smaller entities. Concerns have been raised about the commercial impact on the art market, including increased administrative costs, delays in completing transactions, and intrusive obligations on established commercial relationships. Practical issues, such as implementing correct procedures at art fairs where sales are often completed quickly, also pose challenges. The long-term efficacy and market impact of these AML obligations are still unclear, particularly given the disruptions caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.
Potential Reforms and Future Outlook
Reforming AML regulations to make them more equitable and effective could involve several approaches. One suggestion is to ensure global consistency between regulations to reduce confusion and complexity, especially given the diverse nature of the art market. Additionally, there could be a focus on basing regulatory schemes more on firm facts rather than beliefs, to ensure that the regulations are targeted and effective.
The inclusion of digital art and collectibles under the definition of “works of art” is also being considered. With the rise of non-fungible tokens (NFTs) and online sales, the art market is expanding into new media. This creates novel financial opportunities but also presents new challenges for AML compliance. Regulators in the US and UK are exploring how AML regulations can be adapted to cover these emerging areas of the art market.
Conclusion
Understanding the complexities of Anti-Money Laundering (AML) regulations is essential for Art Market Participants (AMPs) to ensure compliance and prevent money laundering in the art sector. The recent updates to the UK’s AML guidelines have clarified the roles of intermediaries and simplified “Know Your Customer” (KYC) checks, making compliance more manageable.
As the art market continues to evolve, it is essential for AMPs to stay informed and adapt to new developments. Ongoing collaboration between the art market and regulators is vital to ensure that AML regulations remain effective and equitable.
For art market participants seeking to enhance their AML compliance, our courses at KYC Lookup provide the necessary knowledge and skills. Our training programs are designed to help you understand your obligations and implement effective compliance procedures. Visit our courses page to learn more about how we can assist you in meeting your AML compliance needs.
No Comments